Romanian Orthodox for Enquiry in America

Guardians of the Vatra

Orthodox Brotherhood Documents

ROAA/BOR Documents

AB Demetrios Denies Report

Author: AB Demetrios
April 29, 2010
Archbishop Demetrios Visits Ecumenical Patriarchate and Athens;
Calls Media Reports [from the National Herald] False

from the GOA press office and found on

ART. 2
26-28 MAY 2010 NEW YORK

New York-Archbishop Demetrios of America made a five-day trip to Constantinople and Athens. He arrived in Phanar on Friday, April 23 - the feast of the St. George the Trophybearer - in order for his visit to coincide with the visit of His Beatitude Theophilos III, Patriarch of Jerusalem to the Ecumenical Patriarchate.

The next day, the Archbishop was present at the official welcome of the Patriarch of Jerusalem and his delegation of Hierarchs and clergy who had come from the Holy Land for the re-opening of the Jerusalem Patriarchal Metochion of St. George in Neochori. After the formal reception of His Beatitude, the Archbishop participated in a meeting with the two Patriarchs and other Hierarchs aiming at a final resolution of pending issues related to the Palestinian-Jordanian communities in the United States, which concluded successfully.

On Sunday, April 25, the Archbishop attended the Divine Liturgy with His All Holiness. The Liturgy was celebrated by the Patriarch of Jerusalem and his synodia in the Metochion of St. George. In the afternoon, Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew in a special meeting with the Archbishop reviewed the arrangements for the forthcoming Episcopal Assembly of North and Central America.

The next day, the Archbishop traveled to Athens. On Tuesday April 26, the Archbishop visited in succession His Beatitude Archbishop Ieronymos of Athens and All Greece, Prime Minister George Papandreou, Alternate Minister of Foreign Affairs Dimitris Droutsas, and Foreign Affairs Chief of Protocol Ambassador Aikaterini Boura (formerly the Consul General in New York). In all the above cases the Archbishop had substantive discussions concerning Greece and the Omogeneia in the U.S. The Archbishop, during the same day, also had two meetings with the advance teams that prepare Ionian Village for the summer sessions.

Upon his arrival in New York yesterday, Archbishop Demetrios was informed about some false reports in the Media referring to information of a supposed resignation. His Eminence stated categorically that the reports were baseless and patently false. The Archbishop further added that there is no discussion about any resignation whatsoever. He said that he is looking forward in the coming years to the continuation of the sacred and vital mission and work of the Holy Greek Orthodox Archdiocese of America, with the same faith, zeal, methodical planning and love, especially in view of the difficulties confronting our contemporary world.

14 Comments to “AB Demetrios Denies Report”

  1. Administrator Says:

    This explanation of the recent trip made by AB Demetrios to Constantinople and Athens does not negate the possibility of disagreements between the Archbishop and Patriarch Bartholemew regarding the Orthodox Church in North America.

    It is becoming clear that the Episcopal Assembly for North America is not necessarily proceeding as originally planned by Old World Patriarchs who have always tried to keep control of “their” “diasporas”. The 40 year old reality of the OCA is complicating their game. Let us hope that AB Demetrios will stand aright in the face of the the assault that has already begun against him.

  2. Administrator Says:

    Aceasta explicatie despre voiajul recent al IPS Demetrios la Constantinopol si Atena nu neaga posibilitatea de diferente importante intre Arhiepiscopul si Patriarhul Bartolomeu despre Biserica Ortodoxa in America de Nord.

    Devine din ce in ce mai clar ca Adunarea Episcopala pentru America de Nord nu procedeaza asa cum au planificat-o Patriarhii din lumea veche care in tot timpul au incercat sa mentina un control peste “diaspora” “lor”. Realitatea OCA de 40 de ani complica jocul lor. Sa speram ca IPS Demetrios va sta drept in fata asaltului déjà inceput impotriva sa.

  3. Scott Pennigton Says:

    as posted on blog ‘Comments’ section regarding “AB Demetrios Denies Report”

    So . . . how reputable is the National Herald with respect to reporting of this kind? Do they have a track record?

  4. George Michalopulos Says:

    as posted on blog ‘Comments’ section regarding “AB Demetrios Denies Report”

    … I can confidently assert that Kalmoukos does have his agenda but having said that, he has always been on the mark. I’m quite sure that he has sources inside 79th Street. He certainly has sources in Boston. If I may speculate, things are escalating in Diaspora World: a certain “metropolitan” decided to try and take out the current archbishop and two potential rivals at the same time. The dreaded name was actually mentioned, tarring one of these potential rivals by association. I thought long and hard about being dismissive about faux metropolitans but now TNR has given me license to do so. Also, I’ve wondered about whether the Palestinians accepted their transfer to the GOA, looks like they haven’t. And probably won’t. Stay tuned…

  5. Harry Coin Says:

    as posted on blog ‘Comments’ section regarding “AB Demetrios Denies Report”

    Yes. In the past the facts asserted in Kalmoukos’ stories have turned out to be accurate. Of course not all the relevant facts appear in every story, remember his is a Greek language newspaper printed in New York, that’s his audience, those are his customers. However, he was a seminarian many years ago and definitely has inside access and amazing sources overseas. Not much happens in the G world that Ted Kalmoukos doesn’t know before nearly anyone else.

  6. Scott Pennigton Says:

    as posted on blog ‘Comments’ section regarding “AB Demetrios Denies Report”

    Well, if the original story was true, I suppose this indicates that Archbishop Demetrios isn’t going without a fight.

  7. George Michalopulos Says:

    as posted on blog ‘Comments’ section regarding “AB Demetrios Denies Report”

    … In the culture of the Phanar, they may feel that they have no other choice. If so, it will be the latest in a long line of disastrous actions going all the way back to 1991. I know this sounds harsh, because I mean no ill-will to the man or the institution, it’s just that the ecumenical patriarchates is now at the tail-end of 1,000 years of subservience to Caesar/Sultan and they simply don’t know of any other way to function. The culture that this position is engulfed in is endemically inept, even if the office holder himself isn’t.

    Think of it: when they booted out +Iakovos, they thought that +Spyridon would be a good replacement. Why? Because he was born in America. Ergo: the Greek-Americans will love him. Now they think that Lambrianides will fill the bill; why? because he’s young and educated! They simply don’t get the fact that the Church is an organic institution and that wherever it implants itself, it takes on the color of the culture and then christianizes the culture. This means that it becomes native. It follows then that natives will rise from within that culture to pastor the congregations. If on the other hand the Church continues to view itself as a colonial outpost/cash-cow for the Empire, then it will wither.

  8. Bruce Wm. Trakas Says:

    as posted on blog ‘Comments’ section regarding “AB Demetrios Denies Report”

    Well here’s what I think, just guessing. Kalmoulkos is afraid the OCA will lead an autocephalous movement. He has interlocutors at the Phanar and aroused them over this issue. Archbishop Demetrios has never been the Patriarch’s man. +Demetrios played a significant role in negotiating within the Patriarchal Synod, the matter of the break in Communion with the Archbishop of Athens and All Greece, Christoudolos, of blessed memory; a role that the Patriarch found too aggressive. (+Demetrios did mollify what the Patriarch was seeking in terms of the language of the sanction.)

    He is also the right man to foster mechanisms for the unified work of Holy Orthodoxy in America, as opposed to a typical Phanar guy, like +Spyridon, or Fr. Elpidoforos (Is that his name?), the Secretary of the Holy and Sacred Synod. Archbishop Demetrios is respected by his fellow SCOBA hierarchs. A patriarchal man would would operate the Episcopal Assembly with the principle of Byzantine intrigue, accomplishing nothing of substance other than promotion of the Patriarchate. Also, while Archbishop Demetrios is not insubordinate, he negotiates the more bizarre directives from the Patriarchate, while +Bartholomew expects absolute (and “perfect”) compliance. Recall the language of Archbishop Spyridon’s response at the Greater Mandate ceremony in 1996.

    Since his 80th birthday, the Patriarchate has shown shown signs that they think Archbishop Demetrios has served his purpose, uniting the Holy Archdiocese from the mess created during +Spyridon’s archepiscopacy. So probably with the Patriarch’s knowledge, they didn’t mind watching what effects Kalmoulkos’ false reports, which could only help with their agenda of creating chaos, which they think will benefit their agenda ultimately. I know this is quite an unfounded stretch, but it’s based on circumstances I’ve observed during Patriarch Bartholomew’s tenure.

  9. Isa Almisry Says:

    as posted on blog ‘Comments’ section regarding “AB Demetrios Denies Report”

    Recall the language of Archbishop Spyridon’s response at the Greater Mandate ceremony in 1996. What was that? As for Archb. Demetrios, Met. Jonah has expressed his full confidence inn him, which of course would be the kiss of death in the Phanar. The Chief Secretary is the ilk they want to run the EA in America into the ground under the Phanar’s feet.

  10. Bruce Wm. Trakas Says:

    as posted on blog ‘Comments’ section regarding “AB Demetrios Denies Report”

    “By Archbishop Spyridon Upon His Election to the Archepiscopal Throne of America -
    During the Ceremony of the Minor Announcement”

    The Phanar-July 30, 1996: “Your All Holiness, God-Chosen Father and Shepherd,
    “… As I stand in this holy place, I consider it my duty to clearly declare that in my task to fulfill the responsibilities of the new and extensive ministry entrusted to me today, my dedication to your most venerable person and to the Great Church of Christ, which nurtured me, will be complete and whole hearted, and my obedience to Her mandates absolute and perfect. Furthermore, I wish to assure Your All Holiness that the first and primary concern of my ministry in the Western Hemisphere will be to ensure growth of relations and bonds between the pious Orthodox faithful and the Mother Church…”

    I had to find a book to get the exact quote, and upon reading, I was reminded, the Patriarch’s address is even more revealing. It follows.

    “…You bear many qualifications, the crowning qualification of which is your unlimited fidelity and devotion to this venerable Ecumenical Throne, to the Mother Church which nourishes our pious people and all the pious and Orthodox Christians under heaven. It was to this last virtue of yours over all the others that the Mother Church looked when reaching her decision. For even if one of her hierarchs has every talent, every qualification, and all other virtues, but does not have unlimited devotion and blind loyalty and lifelong gratitude, he has nothing, nothing is gained, he is but a noisy gong or a clanging cymbal ( I Cor. 13)…”

  11. George Michalopulos Says:

    as posted on blog ‘Comments’ section regarding “AB Demetrios Denies Report”

    Bruce, what a travesty! The actual quote from Paul is not “blind loyalty” but “love.” This is almost cultic (in the negative sense of the word.)

  12. Harry Coin Says:

    as posted on blog ‘Comments’ section regarding “AB Demetrios Denies Report”

    Notice that this sort of ‘loyalty oath’ thing happens elsewhere in the church than the GOA (you’d think the Creed would be enough). Anyhow notice the letter used by Archbishop Nathaniel mentioning a ‘loyatly oath’ to Fr. Susan published during that controversy.

    Anyhow, you know, please give generously, no doubt the people who’ve taken loyalty oaths to other people will certainly account for your donation honestly, and will pay careful attention to whatever the text might be in agreements published broadly to gain your trusted support.

  13. Fr. Johannes Jacobse Says:

    as posted on blog ‘Comments’ section regarding “AB Demetrios Denies Report”

    It’s not an unfounded stretch at all. I think your analysis is entirely reasonable. In the ten years since the destruction of Ligonier (did former Abp. Iakovos see the future?), what really has been accomplished by Constantinople? Not much apart from political self-aggrandizement including:

    1) Estonia,
    2) Global warming, (including the marshaling the entire infrastructure of the GOA in service to global warming activism including the passage of the Geneva Protocols — a statist program that was the brainchild of EU bureaucrats),
    3) Coddling Castro,
    4) Subsuming the Gospel to a self-serving historical redefinition of Hellenism and replacing the universality of the Gospel with the putative universality of the redefinition,
    5) Coddling American Progressives by giving the false impression that the Orthodox moral tradition and Progressive ideals are synonymous,
    6) Abandoning the moral tradition in critical cultural debates like abortion,
    7) Dividing the fledgling Church in Indonesia,
    8 ) Fostering an increasing authoritarianism in the GOA hierarchical culture and destabilizing clergy families and parishes as a result,
    9) Ham-fisted (Byzantine?) administrative offensives like Fr. Elpidophoros’ speech at Holy Cross (essentially a demand for administrative control), Orphangate, and most recently the transparent attempt to remove Abp. Demetrios (confirming Orphangate in the process).*
    10) Surreptitious destabilization of the Chambesy Accords (if Kalmoukas is correct which he probably is since it fits the template), and more I’m sure.

    I acknowledge, respect and will even the defend the primacy of Constantinople on historical grounds. But I am hard pressed to find anything that isn’t calculated to serve Constantinople’s political self-interest and see the the employment of its historical authority in service to these interests as illegitimate. For the progress of the American Orthodox Church, the leadership of Constantinople has been a failure.
    *(Constantinople does not comprehend that Americans offer all leaders a large presumption of goodwill. Once that goodwill is betrayed however, Americans easily see the ham-fisted/Byzantine machinations for what they are and dismiss them. Constantinople responds with a predictable heavy-handedness that grows heavier each time. They are oblivious to the fact that each offensive increases the chance of greater back-fire and don’t understand why they keep failing. What’s coming forward in these conflicts (especially the administrative offensives) is a very deep element of the American cultural character. Americans are reluctant to obey putative claims of authority that are not backed-up with any substance beyond a hammer. Constantinople interprets the reluctance as recalcitrance and insubordination and responds the only way they know how — with increasing authoritarianism. [This too explains why the hierarchical culture in the GOA is becoming increasingly authoritarian. It will remain that way until GOA bishops break free, something we may not soon see since Constantinople holds approval rights over the American episcopacy in the GOA.])

  14. George Michalopulos Says:

    as posted on blog ‘Comments’ section regarding “AB Demetrios Denies Report”

    Fr, let’s not forget another blunder made by the Phanar. With the publication of that letter to the editor last October and the mishandling of the Polish bishops in South America, +Demetrius has been seriously undercut as chairman of the upcoming Episcopal Assembly. He’s been knocked back on his heels. Now, we can speculate that that’s exactly what the Phanar wants but in doing so, they’re shooting themselves in the foot. Don’t they realize that regardless of any disagreements they may have with +Demetrios, he’s still their man? They were able to salvage the fig leaf of Constantinopolitan chairmanship of these assemblies after all. Now we could say that in that case, it doesn’t matter if he was forced out and replaced with another GOA bishop, but in reality, it undermines the overall stability of the GOA in that it raises the hackles of all other non-GOA bishops.

    Let’s not forget that for all the pretty talk and inscrutable detail in the Chambesy report, there are many “escape hatches.” The number one being that every eparchy is still distinct and retains its own peculiarities. Number two is that every eparchy retains its ties to its mother church. Number three, there is no real deadline set in stone. We are instead told that things must settled before the Great and Holy Council meets but given the fractiousness of the Old World patriarchates, that may take place on the first of Never. As for the intricacies of Orthodox life in America, there are too many people who have a vested interest in keeping things divided, including priests who want to jurisdiction-hop, parishes that want to do the same (as did the mission parish in Fargo which left AOCNA and went to the OCA), and of course parishioners who want to leave for whatever reasons.

Leave a Comment;

E-Mail addresses will not be displayed and will only be used for e-mail notifications.
Not all of your comments are necessarily displayed on this website.
Comments are not necessarily those of is the website of "Romanian Orthodox for Enquiry in America" and is not affiliated with the Romanian Orthodox Episcopate of America (ROEA) or with the Orthodox Church in America (OCA).


O Lord and Master of my life,
leave me not with the spirit of laziness,
of despair, of domination, or idle words.

Rather, give me, your servant, the spirit of integrity,
of humility, of patience, and of love.

Thus, Lord, grant me the wisdom to see my own faults,
and not condemn my brother;

for You are blessed, now and forever. Amen.


Our Father, who are in heaven,
hallowed be Your name.

Your kingdom come.
Your will be done,
on earth as it is in heaven.

Give us this day
our daily bread,
and forgive us our trespasses,
as we forgive those
who trespass against us.

And lead us not into temptation,
but deliver us from evil.